What’s the difference between a GUT and a TOE? Why is unifying the forces of nature so hard? And why do physicists keep trying anyway? I discuss these questions and more in today’s Ask a Spaceman!
Support the show: http://www.patreon.com/pmsutter
All episodes: http://www.AskASpaceman.com
Watch on YouTube: http://www.youtube.com/PaulMSutter
Read a book: https://www.pmsutter.com/books
Keep those questions about space, science, astronomy, astrophysics, physics, and cosmology coming to #AskASpaceman for COMPLETE KNOWLEDGE OF TIME AND SPACE!
Big thanks to my top Patreon supporters this month: Justin G, Chris L, Alberto M, Corey D, Michael P, Naila, Sam R, Joshua, Scott M, Rob H, Scott M, Louis M, John W, Alexis, Gilbert M, Rob W, Jessica M, Jules R, Jim L, David S, Scott R, Heather, Mike S, Pete H, Steve S, Lisa R, Kevin B, Aileen G, Michael J, Phillip L, Steven B, Mark R, Alan B, Craig B, Richard K, Joe R, David P, Justin, Tracy F, Thomas K, James C, Syamkumar M, Mark D, Bruce A, Tim Z, Linda C, The Tired Jedi, Bob C, Stephen A, James R, Allen E, Michael S, Sheryl, David W, Chris, Michael S, Erlend A, James D, Karl W, Edward K, Scott K, Vivek D, M0PPET, Brad, Azra K, Steve R, M D Malahy, Brian O, Alonna M, Joseph B, Anders J, Blaine, Ry Guy, and Phil!
Hosted by Paul M. Sutter.
All Episodes | Support | iTunes | Spotify | YouTube
EPISODE TRANSCRIPT (AUTO-GENERATED)
We've got a problem, folks. And that problem is unification. We all know there are four known fundamental forces of nature. Please do not get me started on speculative fifth forces of nature, or maybe get me started. I don't know. I'm willing to do an episode on it, but not today. Four forces for today. Electromagnetism, gravity, weak nuclear, and strong nuclear. And physics has been on kind of a thing for the past, depending on how you count this, it's either the past 100 years or, you know, 250 years, maybe 300, I'll get to that later. It's been on a thing about unifying these forces.
And what we mean by unification is a very subtle, mathematical thing. What we're trying to do is find a single equation, or we are willing to accept a set of equations, but those equations have to be connected together, a single set of equations that describes more than one force at a time.
That's the whole deal. That's what unification is. In general, in physics, we enjoy this concept that we call parsimony. Parsimony is what is the simplest possible way to explain the most amount of things. That's how we judge the viability of theories before we've tested them with experiment. And we only add extensions to theories and models when we absolutely have to, once we encounter new evidence, new data, new phenomena. Unification is the ultimate expression of this concept of parsimony. Can we write down a singular equation or, you know, set of equations that describes all of it? The entire, all four known forces of nature. And from that one equation, can we then derive the electromagnetic force, the weak and strong nuclear forces, and gravity? That's what we're after.
It's been, well, it's been a bit of an uphill battle, folks. For the past 100 years, ever since we really got rolling on this unification train, there have been a string of failures, honestly. Einstein spent 30 years of his life chasing a theory that merged gravity with electromagnetism. Yes, he was aware of developments in the weak and strong nuclear forces, but he didn't stay super connected to the emergence of those theories, and so he focused on the two, you know, OG theories of gravity and electromagnetism. His last calculations were next to his hospital bed at his death. Looking back at it, Wolfgang Pauli, he had this wonderful quote, he was reflecting on Einstein's attempts to unify theories of nature that appear to be so different. And he said, quote, what God has put asunder let no man join. Meaning that if not even Einstein could do it, then who could?
I mean, to be fair, Pauli himself thought he could, along with basically every major and minor physicist in the past 100 years. They've all done their part to take a shot at it, to find that holy grail, that singular equation that describes it all. In 1958, Pauli and Werner Heisenberg announced a unified theory, but right away, Pauli soured on it. He realized it was a mistake. It was not a unified theory. It was not sound. It was not based on any good evidence or reasoning. He ended up mailing friends a drawing of a blank rectangle, and he said, quote, this is to show the world that I can paint like Titian. Only technical details are missing.
And that pretty much sums up every attempt at a unified theory. Everyone's like, oh, no, no, no, I've got the idea. I know the general picture. I know how to get there. You know, I'm the one who's going to unify all of physics. There are just some minor technical details to work out, and that'll take a little bit of effort, but then we'll be fine.
In 1980, Stephen Hawking, in his inaugural lecture as the Lucasian Professor at Cambridge (this is the same post that Newton held), said that he predicted that it'd be roughly even odds of developing a unified theory by the year 2000. In 2002, a couple years after that came and went, he argued that we might never get there. Steven Weinberg, one of the masters of modern physics, wrote a book in 1992 called Dreams of a Final Theory. Yeah, dreams.
We call that unified theory a theory of everything. A single set of equations that describes it all, that you could use, in principle, if you worked hard enough, to derive and explain every physical interaction in the universe. From chemical signals racing down your nerves to the expansion history of the cosmos, it would all be contained in there. But it's hard. It's really, really hard. We've felt for over 100 years now that we've come close that we're just around the corner. We've got our little rectangle here. We just need to fill in the technical details. But then every time we go to fill in the technical details, what comes out is incomplete, inadequate, inconsistent, or just plain nonsense.
And one of the problems is that we're not exactly sure what we're aiming for. We know the contours of the problem, but that's about it. We know many of the issues we're trying to surmount, but it's harder to go past that.
For example, we know that gravity is ridiculously weak. If I put two protons together in an atom, the electric force between them is stronger than gravity by a factor of 10 to the 36. All it takes is the metal in your fridge to counteract the entire gravitational might of the earth to hold up your magnet. We know that gravity is exceptionally weak. We don't know why. A theory of everything, aka a TOE, would have to explain that. And we find no easy, natural way to fold that weakness of gravity into a theory that works. And that's just one issue of like a hundred issues that we're trying to solve and incorporate into a singular cohesive theory of everything.
But what's so tantalizing about this is that our program of unification has been going really well so far, at least if you don't include gravity. We discovered in both theory and collider experiments that at high energies, the weak nuclear force and the electromagnetic force merge into one. This means that there's a single mathematical equation, a set of equations, that describes this unified force, and we are able to recreate this unified force in our particle accelerators.
Literally, at these high energies, these two forces of nature disappear, which is wild to think about, because electromagnetism has infinite range. It's carried by a single massless, chargeless particle called the photon. While the weak nuclear force is extremely short range, it's carried by three very massive particles, two of them charged and one neutral. They look absolutely nothing alike. And if you were to say, yeah, I want to write down a single equation that describes all this, well, people would think you're crazy. And they'd be right. I mean, you might also be crazy, but in this case, you'd be correct. And at high energies, these two forces disappear and are replaced by a single force that we call the electroweak force.
So the merging of forces can work. And we know that the unification game, if we play it right, can yield results. But the question is now, see, you can't just write down a single equation because the different forces of nature behave differently at different energies. And that's been the key to unlocking unification so far: that the strength of the forces changes with energy. For example, take the electromagnetic force. The strength of the electromagnetic force is about one over 137. This is the fine structure constant. That strength gets stronger at higher energy. So the nature of the forces change with different energies. The more energy is present, the more intense a reaction is, the more the fundamental forces of nature change how they operate. And at some point they blend together. And that's been our road to building unification.
That's why we suspect that if we go to even higher energies, the strong nuclear force merges together with the other two. Because even though the strong nuclear force is actually super duper strong, hence the name, as energies get higher, the strong nuclear force actually gets weaker. And so we can predict an energy scale. If we were to run an experiment with enough energy, the electromagnetic force will get stronger, the weak nuclear force will get a little bit weaker, and the strong nuclear force will get a lot weaker. And then there's a meeting point where they all meld together. And it's at this scale, in terms of energy, where we believe that three of the four forces of nature become a single unified entity.
Now, the trouble with this is that we can't directly access it with experiment. The energy required is about a trillion times higher than what we can do in the Large Hadron Collider. So unlike with the unification of weak nuclear and electromagnetism, where we could directly access this regime, this different reality, this, you know, unified world, accessing it directly in the laboratory so we can compare notes with theory, so we can calibrate, so we can adjust, we could figure it out. We just, we just can't do it.
So the only way to do it is indirectly. If we can't recreate the conditions where the strong, weak, and electromagnetic forces are blended together, then what we are left with is, okay, give me a theory of the unification of these three forces. We call these theories GUTs, for grand unified theories. Then are there other predictions that we can make? Is there anything else we could say about the universe? If we can't directly access these energies where we can see for ourselves, is there anything else we could say? Does the wind blow in a different direction on Tuesday afternoons because this particular grand unified theory is correct? Do the stars appear at a certain rate in cosmic history because the whole grand unified picture is generally correct even if we don't know the details, etc., etc.
Well, there is one such prediction, and it has to do with the decay of the proton. The weird thing about protons and neutrons is that even though they're buddies in an atom, when you pluck them apart, they behave completely differently. If you pull a neutron out of an atom, it's actually unstable. It will spontaneously decay and disappear in about 15 minutes. But if you pluck a proton out of an atom and let it sit there, it will still be a proton. You come back the next day, still a proton. Check back a week later. Yep, still a proton. Hasn't gone anywhere. The proton appears to be stable.
But the interior of a proton isn't just a single entity. It's actually one of the most complex things in all of creation. It's this buzzing sack of strong force particles and energies of quarks and gluons. And so grand unified theories, or GUTs, they alter our picture of how the strong force works in all cases and change our picture of a proton ever so slightly. It's not big. It's not big at all, it's a very, very subtle change. But most grand unified theories, at least generically predict that protons are not entirely 100% stable. That our conceptions of the strong force are just, just a little bit off, even at normal, typical everyday energies.
These theories predict that a proton has a lifetime of, it's a long time. It's like 10 to the 29, 10 to the 31 years. That's an exceedingly long time. That's multiple orders of magnitude. That's like a billion, billion, billion. Maybe I'm overcounting the billions, but it's a lot of billions times older than the current age of the universe. So even though our universe has been around for 14 billion years, any one proton is unlikely to have decayed in that amount of time. But we can still test this. We can still access this. And that's by assembling a whole lot of protons. So if you say, if you have, say, I don't know, 50,000 tons of water, you've got around 10 to the 34 protons on your hands. And if a single proton lasts on average, 10 to the 34 years, but there's a lot of variation around that where some of them do decay sooner than that, then you should expect to see about one decay a year.
And we've run these experiments. And we haven't seen a single proton decay, ever. And while this doesn't rule out grand unified theories, it tells us that if the proton is unstable and eventually does decay, it's on a much longer time scale than we thought.
And so grand unified theories, GUTs, which themselves aren't even a complete theory of everything, have been a difficult program to maintain, I'll be honest, over the past couple decades, because it seems very reasonable. We have good grounding with electromagnetism, weak nuclear. We know the energy scale where we should see unification. There's a lot of physical motivation for these theories. We have a pretty good handle on the strong force itself, et cetera, et cetera. And yet this keystone observation is just not bearing fruit.
And that doesn't even get us started on theories of everything. And theories of everything, like I mentioned earlier, you know, at least with GUTs, you know, we know what we're working with. It's the same kind of thing. It's just a different scale of problem. Electromagnetism, weak nuclear, strong nuclear, even though they manifest differently, even though they act differently, it's the same basic kind of thing. We have the same basic kind of mathematics that describes all three forces, and that mathematics is quantum field theory.
And this is what makes gravity so difficult, because gravity doesn't have a quantum description. The analogy I like is actors on a stage. The actors are the photons, the electrons, the Z bosons, the Higgs boson. They all walk across the stage, they interact with each other, they talk, they do interesting things, they entertain us, and then they walk off. We've developed a very powerful set of techniques (these are called the quantum field theories) to describe those actors and how they interact with each other. The goal of electroweak unification and grand unified theories in general is to prove that these different characters that appear on the stage are really the same actor, just wearing a different mask every time they show up. That quest has been moderately successful. We're not exactly sure who's behind the mask or the costume of the strong nuclear force, and if it's the same actor or not. But we do know for sure that the actor behind the weak force and the electromagnetic force is the same person, just wearing a different costume.
Gravity is different. Gravity is the stage itself. In the old Newtonian world, the stage was fixed. It was just space and time, and you just marked out your distances, and then the characters did their thing on the stage. You didn't have to worry about this stage much because space and time were just the place where stuff happens. But then Einstein realized that gravity and spacetime are the same thing. As John Wheeler put it, spacetime tells matter how to move, and matter tells spacetime how to bend. So the stage that the actors are walking on is itself moving and responding as the actors walk. They create dimples and waves and the motion of other actors is influenced by actors that aren't even talking to them, but just existing on another part of the stage and shaping the floor underneath them. The force of gravity comes alive through the stage we live on.
So the game of unification has been to find the actors behind the masks and underneath the costumes and to prove that it's all the same actor. But then there's gravity who's now taking a starring role, but it's not a character that's walking on the stage, it is the stage. And yet it's part of the show. So how the heck do you prove that not only are the characters on the stage being played by the same actor, but the stage itself is being played by the same actor?
This is a metaphor, of course. But what really matters is the math, and the math here is even worse than the metaphor implies, which is quite a feat. Every time we try to abandon this gravity and spacetime language, every time we try to say, okay, okay, gravity may look like the bending of spacetime, and that's a very good description. Thank you, Einstein. Big applause. Pat on the back for you. But we're going to find a quantum field theory description of gravity so we can put it back on stage so gravity can be a character just like everybody else. And then from there, we will play our unification game and discover the identities of the actors behind the masks and the costumes. Well, I mean, every time we try that, everything blows up. All of our quantum field descriptions just spit out infinities, spit out nonsense, which makes sense in a way, because we're trying to turn the stage into a character and that doesn't go well.
This is exactly the program behind string theory, by the way. String theory just stops talking about curved spacetime. It assumes that we live in a flat universe. The stage is now fixed. And the actors are really vibrating strings. And if you peeked behind the mask and the costume of every other actor, you would just find a string vibrating at a different frequency. And gravity would just be another character on the stage, another kind of vibrating string doing its thing. And string theory hasn't exactly worked out despite half a century of work on it.
Nor have all the other ideas. Every time we try to promote gravity to be an actor, to treat it like a quantum object, it falls apart. And we know that quantum mechanics is really, really good at describing the world. So this is a frustrating place to be.
Physicists have spent a century trying to unify the four forces of nature with mixed results. But there is a much easier unification problem, gathering everyone together to contribute to Patreon. That's patreon.com/pmsutter. And it's your contributions that unify this show. And unlike a theory of everything, there are no technical details missing. You just go to patreon.com/pmsutter. I really do appreciate it.
Yeah, unification has not been great, but we don't give up. Come on. We don't give up because we have centuries under our belt of this program of unification. The first one to do it mathematically was Newton himself. He looked at the wide variety of physical phenomena and realized that they could be described by a single force. He looked at the apple falling from the tree. He looked at the moon and orbit around the earth. And he realized he could describe it all with the exact same thing. He even gave the words force and gravity the precise meanings that physics still uses today. He unified motion across the entire universe.
In the 1800s, Maxwell, you know me and Maxwell. He took three completely different theories: electricity, magnetism, and light itself. Electricity is radically different than magnetism. Magnetism is radically different than electricity. And both of them are completely and totally unrelated to light. You would never think in a million years, unless you're James Clerk Maxwell, that these three things could be described by a single set of equations that show how they're all connected, just different sides of the same three-sided coin. Okay, I wasn't exactly sure where I was going with that metaphor. But you get the idea. You would never think that a single equation could describe all of that at the same time. Just like you would never think that a single equation would describe the motion of an apple falling to the earth and the orbit of the moon around the earth.
And then we unified them. And when we discovered a brand new force in the middle of the 20th century, the weak nuclear force, we figured out how to unify it with electromagnetism. So we've got this unification bug. We unified motion. We unified electricity and magnetism and light. We unified the weak nuclear force. It's been a really, really powerful, fruitful idea. It's led us to insights. I mean, we can describe the state of the universe when it was like 10 to the minus 10 seconds old, thanks to our unified theories of physics. Come on, that's remarkable, right? Let's give physics itself a pat on the back here. We've been doing a pretty good job.
Until now. Grand unified theories, theories of everything, seem plausible. They're hard to argue against, but they're also having a hard time standing up to experiment or generating, in the case of theories of everything, predictions that can be compared to experiment. Every attempt at a theory of everything gets lost in a mathematical maze. Every attempt at a grand unified theory doesn't survive scrutiny of experiment. Do we give up now? Well, if physicists, if scientists gave up every time they faced a hard problem, well, we wouldn't have gotten very far, would we?
Thanks to Alex C for the question that led to today's episode. Please keep those questions coming to askaspaceman@gmail.com or just go to the website, askaspaceman.com. Keep the reviews going on your favorite podcasting platform. It really helps the show visibility. It's a really easy way to help promote the show and keep this show going. But of course, the most important thing are the questions. Those are what I care about most. If you do have some spare dollars, I would also appreciate a contribution to Patreon. That's patreon.com/pmsutter. I'd like to thank my top contributors this month. They're Justin G, Chris L, Alberto M, Corey D, Michael P, Naila, Sam R, Joshua, Scott M, Rob H, Scott M, Louis M, John W, Alexis, Gilbert M, Rob W, Jessica M, Jules R, Jim L, David S, Scott R, Heather, Mike S, Pete H, Steve S, Lisa R, Kevin B, Aileen G, Deb A, Michael J, Phillip L, and Steven B. Thank you to everyone who contributes. patreon.com/pmsutter. And I will see you next time for more complete knowledge of time and space.